Maurene Comey worked for the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York. She excelled at that post. She helped prosecute Sean Diddy Combs, Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Sen, Robert Menendez. But, instead of a pat on the back, the new Trump administration fired her in 2025. She was also the daughter of James Comey. For unknown reasons, Pres. Trump considers James Comey comes one of his most bitter enemies. Maureen Comey received only praise for her work from her supervisors. I previously wrote about the firing of Ms. Comey here.
When the US Attorney General fired Ms. Comey, Jay Clayton simply pointed to the Article II powers of the President. Article II is a broad statement. Citing Article II was tantamount to saying, “We fired you because we wanted to.” Ordinarily, Ms. Comey’s only recourse would have been to the Merit Systems Protection Board. The MSPB was created specifically to hear claims by Federal workers for unfair treatment. And, since, there was no actual written warnings or other discipline, Ms. Comey would have a very strong case in front of the MSPB.
The MSPB
But, the MSPB had and still has no functioning board. The President fired a couple members of the MSPB and did not replace them. So, Ms. Comey bypassed the MSPB and went straight to U.S. District Court. Her lawsuit claims that her termination violated the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978. The CSRA created the MSPB. On appeal the Department of Justice argued that the Attorney General has unlimited power to fire an Assistant US Attorney. But, the U.S. District Court in New York did not agree.
The Court said the firing actually violated the CSRA. The CSRA requires that a Federal employee be fired for cause. That means there must be some articulable reason for the termination. Simply saying, “We fired her because we wanted to” is not enough. The court explained that civil service itself was created in 1883 to prevent the “spoils system” that had existed. Under the spoils system, Federal employees were removed wholesale whenever a New President assumed power. That system was not effective.
Regarding Ms. Comey, DOJ did not deny that it had provided no reason for Ms. Comey’s termination. That is always a weak defense. Citing no reason suggests the real reason is not a good one.
“Borders on Frivolous”
In a brazen sort of defense, DOJ tried to claim that Ms. Comey’s lawsuit was not viable. She should pursue her remedies with the MSPB. But, said the court, Comey was not fired pursuant to the CSRA, so she is not required to pursue remedies under the CSRA. The Court also noted that for forty years, the Executive branch has always acted on the assumption that Assistant US Attorneys must be terminated via the CSRA. The Judge said the Defendant’s argument bordered on “frivolous.” Indeed. The court did not explicitly say so, but it clearly believed Maurene Comey was fired because she was her father’s daughter. It was a weak termination on many levels. The Trump administration essentially handed Ms. Comey a very strong lawsuit.
Both parties submitted motions for judgment on the pleadings. Such motions means both parties are saying to the Judge that they agree on the facts and discovery of the evidence is not necessary. The Court rejected DOJ’s motion and granted Comey’s motion for judgment on the pleadings.
The Court then ordered the reinstatement of Ms. Comey to her former position with lost pay and benefits for the time she has been fired. The decision will surely be appealed. But, seriously, firing the daughter of James Comey with nothing better than “because we want to” invites a sizable lawsuit. This is not a serious department of Justice.
See the decision in Comey v. U.S. Dept. of Justice, No. 25-CV-7625 (S.D. N.Y. Oct. 26, 2026) here. See CBS news report here.









