Crazy things happen in trials. One recent jury in Bexar County apparently took some evidence home. One of the jurors pocketed a picture of a boy in the hospital – who was the subject of an abuse trial. See San Antonio Express News report. A couple of the jurors took pictures home – perhaps
Litigation and trial practice
Credibility Requires a Witness to Recall Just Enough
Depositions are key events in any lawsuit. The Opposing Counsel has the freedom to ask questions that lead to admissible evidence or questions which are reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence. That standard allows a broad range of questions. Most plaintiff employees are understandably nervous about being deposed regarding their case.
Some plaintiffs, for…
Lawyer Cleared of Charges of Unconscionable Fee
Texas ethical rules require that lawyers not charge a client an "unconscionable" fee. There is no precise definition of "unconscionable," but it does mean really, really high fees. A lawyer in West Texas was paid millions of dollars by wrongly convicted inmates. The wrongly convicted inmates receive $80,000 per year in state compensation for every…
Court Sanctions Plaintiff and Lawyer for Facebook Spoliation
"Spoliation of evidence" refers to the deliberate destruction of evidence prior to a trial. It is a rare event in civil litgation. But, spoliation of evidence was found in a case involving a personal inury lawyer in Virginia. Lawyer Matthew Murray was ordered to pay $522,000 for instructing his client ro remove photos from his…
Judges Do Drop Hints
My clients often tell me some horrible deed by the employer and quickly ask me "can they do that?" To me the real question is "will the employer’s act and his explanation pass muster with the judge and jury?" I usually answer by "guestimating" what how a jury would respond. If the client really presses…
Its Hard to Finance a Discrimination Lawsuit
Financing discrimination lawsuits is difficult. The plaintiffs often are unemployed by the time they even find a lawyer. Many potential plaintiffs do not find a lawyer, at all. So, it is not surprising to see three women who are suing DePaul University have set up a website seeking donations for their lawsuit. See their website…
The Vanishing Plaintiff
Legal scholars are becoming more aware that actual trials in federal courts have decreased dramatically since the 1960’s. Suja Thomas discussed this trend in a recent speech at Seattle University to mark the 25th anniversary of the summary judgment trilogy. See Workplace Prof report. Prof. Thomas mentions a couple of developments leading to this…
Plaintiff Depositions Are Critical
I have talked about this before, but it needs repeating. See my prior post. The plaintiff employee deposition is critical to success for any employment lawsuit. The plaintiff employee must be able to show the opposing attorney and the employer that the employee can testify, can present well to a jury and can tell…
Circumstantial Evidence Can Support a Discrimination Claim
Many potential plaintiff employees come see me about a discrimination case and first thing they say is they don’t have evidence. Really? No evidence to show they suffered discrimination? Often, they have evidence but do not realize it.
Yes, discrimination cases are the epitome of "he said, she said." But, there are many forms of…
Employment Lawsuits Require Some Emotional Distance
My colleague and friend, Mike Maslanka, at Work Matters, pens a nice post about questions to pose to the employee plaintiff. See post. Mike’s post discusses good questions to ask the plaintiff. Mike generally represents employers. These questions would usually come during the deposition or the trial. His point is that the better questions…