English Only Rules Spark Controversy

 English only rules always bring controversy, even at a bookstore in New Haven, Connecticut, very near Yale university.  The EEOC generally frowns on such rules, but allows them for "business necessity."   In this case, the book store is essentially claiming the customers are uncomfortable with employees speaking Spanish.  Does the comfort of customers count as a business necessity?  Maybe, according to Workplace Prof.  It depends on whether there is evidence of discriminatory motivations.  That means an employer seeking to implement such a policy needs to show something more than mere perception of what makes a customer happy.  

It would also help to show some safety issue.  ....  Safety at a bookstore?  Those paper cuts can be viscious.....

San Antonio Manager Forbids Speaking Spanish

 I do not what is going on, but there is another story about a Manager allegedly telling her employees not to speak Spanish in the workplace.  See local San Antonio Express News story.  This was regarding a non-profit agency.  Sometimes, I just wish I could give a massive presentation to all Managers and manager wannabes.  Do not tell your employees to speak only English unless you have a very good reason......

New Mexico Hispanics are not Immigrants

 From a more sociological perspective, the San Antonio Express news agrees that requiring New Mexico employees to only speak English is wrong on many levels.  See story.  The Express news adds that New Mexico, of course, was Hispanic long before it became part of the US.  According to the author, Ruben Navarrette, the employees who were fired come from old New Mexico families.  So, they are no immigrants and are speaking their "normal" tongue.  

As I recently posted, an employer who requires employees to only speak English must have a clear business reason.  Otherwise, it will appear that discrimination was a motivating factor.  The employer said he wanted employees to speak English because he was afraid they were talking about him in Spanish.  Sigh.  

The scary thing is the employer lived for many years in Texas and ran businesses here.